Last month El Salvador experienced one of its most dramatic constitutional crises of the past 20 years.
It began when the Constitutional Chamber of the country declared as unconstitutional all the appointments of Supreme Court judges made in 2006 and 2012. The rationale for this decision was that the Legislature that made these appointments had already done so once before at the beginning of the legislative session. The chamber ruled that these second appointments were unconstitutional. The ruling also included another decision that declared unconstitutional the Legislature’s initiative to transfer the current president of the Supreme Court to another chamber and ordered the president to keep his position as President until the end of his term.
The Chamber had ordered the current Legislature to elect judges for nine years and also provided instructions to the Legislature on how to proceed in the future with regard to Supreme Court appointments. Such guidance by the Constitutional Chamber included elements such as transparency, access to information to citizens regarding the qualifications of the nominees; and documented information on the nominees so that the government could justify these appointments on the basis of merit and achievements.
These developments prompted the government of President Mauricio Funes of the left-wing Farabundo Marti National Liberation Party (FMLN) to refuse to accept the ruling. Funes proceeded to mobilize national as well as international support against the Supreme Court decision.
The Salvadorian Constitutional Chamber is one of the five chambers of the Supreme Court. It deals with issues relating to individual protections, habeas corpus, the constitutionality of government decisions and laws; and settling of disputes between the legislative and executive power. Five justices compose the chamber and its president is also the president of the Supreme Court and the entire judicial branch.
Interestingly enough, the Salvadorian Constitutional Chamber has been very active in the last several years in something that is still unusual in Latin America: the struggle for an independent judiciary, one of the key components of a true democracy.
In July, 2010, the Constitutional Chamber declared the national electoral system unconstitutional because the system did not allow for independent candidacies or direct votes to be cast for the candidate of the voter’s preference. Instead, the vote was for the party not the person. This angered the legislature that gathered overnight and passed a constitutional amendment that requires candidates to run for office only through political parties. That was an obvious reaction of the political parties against candidates that emerge outside the establishment and may threaten the power- hungry parties.
The Legislative Assembly followed this decision by adopting decree 743 that required the Constitutional Chamber to make a binding decision; it must have unanimous support among its members. President Funes signed the decree that night. It goes without saying that no court in any democratic-constitutional country works in such a way. In fact, the requirement of unanimity was aimed at strengthening the power of the political branches over the constitution and the eternal and typical attitude of the Latin American political class to see legal and constitutional restraints as an annoyance to their ability to make decisions. We cannot imagine any such situation in a true democracy.
This power grab by the Salvadorian political class against the judiciary brought about national and international protests that eventually forced the Legislature to revoke decree 743.
The recent decision pertaining to the appointment of judges once again sparked a conflict between the judiciary and the legislative and executive branches.
The Regional Involvement in the Salvadorian Crisis
This time, Salvadorian executive authorities decided to bring the case before the Central American Court of Justice (CACJ) that is the judicial branch of the Central American Integration System (SICA).
The CACJ not only admitted the case but also ruled against the decision of the Salvadorian Constitutional Chamber. The Salvadorian Constitutional Chamber declared the CAJC involvement and decision irrelevant and unconstitutional.
However, the Salvadorian Legislature invoked the decision by the CACJ and voted to strip the President of the Supreme Court of his powers by declaring that any member of the Supreme Court could convene a meeting, not just its president.
Thus, the executive and legislative actions endorsed the appointment of the new Supreme Court against the ruling of the Constitutional Chamber thus creating two Supreme Courts.
The Central American International Court of Justice undermined the principle of an independent judiciary by quickly ruling in favor of the Salvadorian Government.
To have an idea about the magnitude of irresponsibility of the CACJ, we can only think about how long it would have taken the U.S. Supreme Court or any normal court to make a decision about such a delicate issue.
I agree that Latin American Supreme and other courts have been deficient throughout the decades. However, in the Salvadorian case, the Supreme Court of Justice was moving in the direction of independence, legality and transparency.
Interestingly enough, the CAJC is based in Managua, Nicaragua, the same country whose government manipulated the Supreme Court in order to subjugate it and subordinate it to the will of the executive power.
For example, early in July, the CAJC criticized Costa Rica over the construction of a highway. The court considered that such a highway would cause environmental damage to the San Juan River which is located in Nicaraguan territory. The Costa Rican government reacted by accusing the CAJC of having a pro-Nicaragua bias.
Two justices of El Salvador, two from Honduras, and two from Nicaragua currently compose the CAJC. Guatemala, Costa Rica and Panama currently have no representation. The president of the Court is from Nicaragua.
Some Reflections from the Salvadoran Case
The Salvadoran case, particularly the behavior of both the legislative and executive branches of government, indicates that in many Latin American countries, politics is still oriented towards quick decisions, minimization of debate and lack of empowerment.
Democracy continues to be sacrificed by short- term interests and politization of all the spheres of government, particularly the judiciary.
But there is an important regional component that cannot be ignored.
Countries of the region have protested and acted against deposed presidents but have not acted against presidential abuse of other branches of government.
In the case of Honduras in 2009, countries of the region sympathized with the deposed president, Mel Zelaya while ignoring his contempt for the decisions made by the legislature and the judiciary in that country.
Barely a month ago, Paraguay was suspended from Mercosur for what its members Argentina, Brazil, and Uruguay defined as “democratic breakdown”, although no other countries except the Bolivarian ones defined the situation in such a way. What is worse these countries took advantage of Paraguay’s suspension to admit Venezuela, the most dictatorial regime in Latin America, to Mercosur (Venezuela’s membership in Mercosur was delayed amid objections by the Paraguayan Congress).
By the same token, the Central American Court of Justice without any hesitation sided with President Funes in the Salvadorian case.
I also believe that Costa Rican concerns over Nicaragua’s undue influence over the CACJ have some merit. If this is, indeed, the case, we may be seeing a propensity towards Nicaraguan regional hegemony in Central America. Taking into account the fact that the government of Daniel Ortega Saavedra is Bolivarian and pro-Chavez, such influence must be taken very seriously.
The harmony that some members of the U.S. Administration describe when they talk about Latin America is only the fruit of their imagination. In the case of Central America, the politicization of the rule of law and the crushing of the courts constitutes another bullet in the heart of institutional integrity which is already seriously wounded by the presence of the drug cartels, corruption and anarchy.
THE AMERICAS REPORT
NANCY MENGES and
LUIS FLEISCHMAN, Editors
The Americas Report is the featured product of the Center for Security Policy‘s Menges Hemispheric Security Project. It features in-depth, original articles on subjects not regularly covered by the American press.
Search The Americas Report
Browse By Topic
- Central American Countries (7)
- Latin American Countries (247)
- Middle East (25)
- Podcast (1)
- #Bolivia Emergencia: Marchan por la falta de agua potable en seis de nueve departamentos December 3, 2016La ineptitud y la corrupción han impactado en el suministro de agua en seis de un total de nueve departamentos en Bolivia, incluyendo la ciudad de La Paz, donde ya no hay agua para consumo de sus habitantes. El partido de Evo Morales, Movimiento al Socialismo (MAS) que dice procurar cientos de servicios "sociales" a […]
- #Colombia A pupitrazo limpio – por Plinio Apuleyo Mendoza December 3, 2016Fue grande el engaño. Enterados de que se estaba trabajando duramente en La Habana para hacer los ajustes solicitados por los expresidentes Uribe y Pastrana, llegamos a pensar que la derrota del Sí había obrado en Santos un saludable efecto. Pero hasta ahí llegó la fina cortesía de Santos. Fríamente anunció que el acuerdo era […]
- #Cuba Prohibido reír, escuchar música, bailar o tomar durante 9 días November 29, 2016El régimen dictatorial de Cuba prohibió a la ciudadanía realizar cualquier tipo de festividad durante los nueve días que dure el duelo decretado en el país por la muerte de Fidel Castro. Entre otras cosas, no se podrá mostrar alegría, escuchar música ni tomar alcohol en público. La represión y la intolerancia continúan sin pausa.
- #Cuba Celebraciones en Miami por la muerte de Fidel Castro November 26, 2016#Cuba Miles de personas se congregan en la calle 8 de Miami, núcleo del movimiento anticastrista, para celebrar una noticia que llevaban mucho tiempo esperando: la muerte del dictador, traidor y asesino, Fidel Castro.
- #Cuba Murió el dictador Fidel Castro: La historia no lo absolverá – por Carlos Alberto Montaner November 26, 2016#Cuba Murió el dictador Fidel Castro: Carlos Alberto Montaner responde 4 preguntas clave sobre el infame dictador: ¿Qué rasgos psicológicos le dieron forma y sentido a su vida, motivando su conducta de conquistador revolucionario, cruce caribeño entre Napoleón y Lenin? ¿Cómo era el mundo en que se formó? ¿En qué creía? ¿Cuál es el balance […]
- #Mexico Enrique Peña Nieto: “Queremos privilegiar el diálogo con Donald Trump para una nueva agenda” November 19, 2016#Mexico En la Cumbre de la APEC en Lima, el Presidente Enrique Peña Nieto afirmó: "Queremos privilegiar el diálogo con Donald Trump para una nueva agenda". Y agregó "El libre comercio ha deparado a prácticamente buena parte de las economías mundiales mayor desarrollo, mayor crecimiento económico, mayor inclusión social", dijo. "México es un ferviente creyente […]
- #Colombia Santos entra en pánico con la elección de Donald Trump – por Mary O’Grady November 14, 2016#Colombia Santos tiene prisa, necesita salirse con la suya antes que Obama termine su mandato. Que le haya llevado al gobierno seis años de negociaciones para firmar el acuerdo con los terroristas de las FARC al que los colombianos le dijeron “NO” y se haya tomado apenas seis semanas para enmendarlo, pone a prueba su […]
- #EEUU Histórico triunfo Republicano en la Casa Blanca, Senado y Diputados November 9, 2016La candidata Hillary Clinton gastó más del doble de dinero en campaña, tuvo a Barack Obama y a la primera dama de los Estados Unidos haciendo campaña para ella con el dinero de los contribuyentes, tuvo a la amplia mayoría de los medios del mundo, a Wall Street, a las compañías financieras, y a la […]
- #Colombia Sin carroza, ni plata, ni paz, ni luz – por Juan Lozano November 8, 2016Sr. Presidente, andan diciendo que usted está muy afanado para poderse llevar el acuerdo listo a la hora de recibir el Nobel y hablar con el Papa. Ojalá se lograra. Pero si el diálogo avanza bien, no vuelva a cometer el mismo error de forzar acuerdos finales a la carrera que arriesgan todo lo logrado. […]
- #Opinion The New Political ism: Egalitarianism – by José Azel November 8, 2016Fascism and Nazism were defeated in World War II. Communism and Socialism were presumably defeated in the Cold War, but they have mutated into a new political ism: egalitarianism. In Equal is Unfair, Don Watkins and Yaron Brook make the case that modern egalitarianism evolves as a comeback to the failure of communism for those […]
- #Bolivia Emergencia: Marchan por la falta de agua potable en seis de nueve departamentos December 3, 2016
- Niños del Estado Islámico asesinan a 25 soldados siriosYihadistas publican video donde aparecen las víctimas de rodillas y en fila en el escenario del teatro romano de Palmira
- Fidel reaparece en reunión de maestros queserosSostuvo un amplio intercambio de más de cuatro horas con 19 maestros queseros en un instituto en el poblado del Guatao
- Enrique Iglesias complace a miles de fansCon I like it, el cantante finalizó su concierto de anoche
- Kutcher y Mila Kunis se casarían este fin de semanaSegún el portal estadounidense Page Six, la pareja dará el sí en una ceremonia privada en Los Angeles
- Niños del Estado Islámico asesinan a 25 soldados sirios