There is a great deal of speculation these days about the immediate political future after Chavez’ expected death.
Some analysts, like Amherst University professor Javier Corrales argue that regardless of what happens, the next government will have to deal with a serious problem left behind by Chavez . This problem centers on the previous irrational approach to government spending in which money was used as an instrument of political influence domestically and abroad. Government officials never worried or valuated whether these expenditures made sense or whether they were creating a huge deficit and debt. Therefore, Corrales believes that the main challenge for Venezuelan leaders will be economic adjustment and that no successor will have the same level of largesse or fiscal irrationality as Chavez had.
However, there are other commentators who focus more on the ideological differences and potential conflicts that may ensue after Chavez’s departure.
They view Chavismo as being deeply divided between the military and the civilian factions. This division was kept together under Chavez but it is likely to explode after the commander’s death.
Nicolas Maduro, the current foreign Minister and the man Chavez appointed as his successor, leads the civilian faction. Maduro has strong ties to the Cuban government and plays a key role in forging alliances with rogue states such as Iran, Syria, and Belarus. He was also instrumental in strengthening alliances with the Bolivarian countries and in raising the status of Venezuela in the region, including its inclusion in the South American common market (MERCOSUR).
The current President of the National Assembly, Diosdado Cabello, leads the military faction. He is more nationalist oriented, has only visited Cuba once, and is not close to the Cuban government. However, Cabello played a role in Chavez’s domestic agenda, particularly in cracking down on the media. He was also instrumental in helping Chavez corrupt the machinery of government in order to strengthen his power. Cabello was part of the group of officers that orchestrated the coup d’état in 1992 that helped Chavez rise to the public scene as an anti-establishment figure.
According to Vladimir Gessen, a former congressman, the military reject the Cuban model and also resent their presence in the Venezuelan military.
Thus, according to his view, the conflict between the two factions could be very serious as the military has played a role in the social missions and eleven of twenty Chavista governors are former military officers. Therefore, Gessen assumes that Cabello will do everything he can to prevent the civilian faction led by Maduro from taking the reins of the Bolivarian Republic.
In my opinion, these analyses are relevant and important to note.
However, I would like to reflect upon the situation from a different angle before relating to the arguments presented above.
Going forward, the first major question to consider is whether the Bolivarian Revolution will change its course. In other words, is there any incentive to change a revolution that has shown considerable success both domestically and abroad? While taking into account Corrales’ serious arguments about the Venezuelan fiscal deficit, it is important to understand that Chavez was not only re-elected in the October 7th elections but also was victorious in the December 16th elections, winning the overwhelming majority of governorships (20 out of 23.) Though these results reflect continued popular support for Chavez, elections in Venezuela are not transparent. Chavez and his cronies have an overwhelming advantage because the Electoral Commission is controlled by the regime as well as large segments of the media.
At the domestic and regional level, Chavez has earned an image as the father of the oppressed, thus his followers believe he is the only leader in the region that has the ability to unite different and diverse sectors of the population. Following the thought of scholars Hannah Fenichel Pitkin and Ernesto Laclau, we can say that, how the constituent is kept satisfied matters less than the symbol the government or the leader represent. Whether or not the Bolivarian Revolution succeeded in fulfilling its promises or whether it has created a fiscal cliff has less weight than the loyalties and identification of its followers. One of the great accomplishments of Chavismo has been its ability to homogenize and bring together a diverse group of people, who now have a sense of representation, unknown to them prior to the revolution.
The collective perception that Chavez and his revolution represent the oppressed and disadvantaged, is crucial, regardless of whether people truly are better off now than they were fourteen years ago. The revolution has also succeeded in blaming the opposition for the problems it has created. The Chavez regime has adopted a patronizing attitude towards the opposition, accusing it polarization, when in truth, the larger polarizing force is the regime itself.
The Bolivarian Revolution has excited the masses, not only in Venezuela, but also across Latin America. It has expanded the revolution to Bolivia, Ecuador and Nicaragua. It is a symbol among the grassroots of the ruling Workers and Peronist Parties in Brazil and Argentina respectively, and the Movement of Popular Participation (MPP), one of the largest sectors in Uruguay’s ruling party, the Broad Front. The Bolivarian Revolution is popular among the indigenous grassroots, including CONAIE, the largest indigenous movement in Ecuador. The revolution has also fascinated important sectors of the intellectual left.
Chavez and his revolution are so powerful that various governments in South America, including that of Brazil, a rising world power, viewed the victory of Chavez in the October elections as a necessary condition for the continuity of regional integration. A proud atheist such as the Uruguayan president, Jose Mujica, took time out of his schedule to pray in a Church for Chavez’s health.
The success of the Bolivarian Revolution provides no incentive to the new leadership in Venezuela to change its course, whether there is economic bankruptcy or internal divisions. Contrary to the Fascist or the Communist Revolutions, the Bolivarian Revolution has neither been challenged nor contained.
Once we have reached this conclusion, we can discuss how, for example, the Maduro-Cabello confrontation might play out. The assertion that the military is anti-Cuban requires a more comprehensive analysis than this piece can cover. However, even if the military were anti-Cuban and succeeded in expelling Cuban advisors and officers from the Venezuelan Armed Forces, this act alone would probably not constitute a major turning point or the end of the Bolivarian Revolution as we know it. One might also ask, is the military now anti-Cuban enough after all the purges that have taken place in the last 14 years and after all the bribery and luxurious life that has been provided to many of the military officers? What role are the 125,000-troop militias likely to play after Chavez’s death? Will the alliance with Iran or the drug cartels end? Will the revolution lose ideological strength? Will it become less hostile to America?
The Bolivarian Revolution does not depend on the Cuban government economically but, rather, the other way around. Nor, does the revolution depend on Cuba for ideological support. In fact, it has already achieved an influence that the Castros never had. The Castro Regime, at its peak, responded to the Soviet Union, whereas, the Bolivarian Revolution maintains its own leadership. The Cubans mostly play a role in assisting the Bolivarian regime in consolidating a repressive and controlling regime.
From a geo-political point of view, governments of the region, including the United States, must look beyond hasty conclusions because, as has been repeatedly pointed out, the Bolivarian Revolution is the most far-reaching and most challenging phenomenon in the Western Hemisphere.
Luis Fleischman is co-editor of the Americas Report and the author of the upcoming book “Latin America in the Post-Chavez Era: The Security Threat to the United States”
THE AMERICAS REPORT
NANCY MENGES and
LUIS FLEISCHMAN, Editors
The Americas Report is the featured product of the Center for Security Policy‘s Menges Hemispheric Security Project. It features in-depth, original articles on subjects not regularly covered by the American press.
Search The Americas Report
Browse By Topic
- Central American Countries (7)
- Latin American Countries (249)
- Middle East (25)
- Podcast (1)
- Las FARC, el Foro de San Paulo y compañía van por todo Latinoamérica – por María Celsa Rodríguez January 11, 2017El grupo terrorista FARC de Colombia y otros grupos peligrosos de la región latinoamericana, luego de la reunión del Foro de Sao Paulo en Europa, parecen haber modificado su estrategia para tomar el poder en toda la región por medio de la violencia, y esta vez lo harán fortalecidos con dinero del Islam radical. De […]
- #Venezuela Maduro huye hacia delante de la mano de Tareck El Aissami – por Carlos Alberto Montaner January 9, 2017Venezuela continúa hundiéndose. La barbarie no conoce límites. La única regla clara es que mañana siempre será peor que hoy. Lo demuestra el nombramiento de Tareck El Aissami, gobernador de Aragua, como primer vicepresidente del país. El periodista venezolano Antonio María Delgado, estudioso del tema, ha escrito en El Nuevo Herald que es una […]
- #Brasil Odebrecht: Lista de los 300 políticos corruptos January 8, 2017Se ha hecho público el listado de los 300 nombres de políticos corruptos mencionados en los documentos secuestrados por la policía federal de Brasil en la etapa número 23 de la Operación Lava Jato. En la misma hay políticos de nivel municipal, provincial y nacional de la República del Brasil. Las investigaciones internacionales y el testimonio de […]
- #Colombia: Miembros “objetivos” de la misión de la ONU de fiesta con terroristas FARC y menores January 3, 2017La agencia EFE hizo públicos varios videos en los que se observa a miembros de la misión de verificación de las Naciones Unidas bailando alcoholizados con terroristas de las FARC durante la pasada noche de fin de año en El Conejo, municipio ubicado en La Guajira, norte de Colombia, con fuerte presencia de prostitutas, muchas de ellas menores […]
- #Brasil Marcelo Odebrecht: “Si empiezo a hablar van a tener que habilitar celdas para varios Presidentes sudamericanos” January 3, 2017Marcelo Odebrecht, brasilero, es el presidente de la compañía de ingeniería y construcción más grande de Latinoamérica: Odebrecht S.A., entre otras cosas, a cargo de la ejecución de obras públicas multimillonarias en distintos países de la región. Marcelo Odebrecht terminó detenido y encarcelado en el año 2015. El Departamento de Justicia de los Estados Unidos reveló […]
- #Argentina Es falso que bajar el gasto público sea recesivo – por Roberto Cachanosky January 3, 2017Si se baja el gasto público y se bajan los impuestos, el nivel de actividad va a ser el mismo Lejos de significar un cambio en la política económica, el reemplazo del ministro de Hacienda con la consiguiente división del ministerio en Hacienda y Finanzas sigue el rumbo del camino anterior aunque, de acuerdo al […]
- #Argentina Cambio estratégico en Ministerio de economía: Sale Prat Gay, ingresa Nicolás Dujovne December 27, 2016Quién es Nicolás Dujovne El desembarco de Nicolás Dujovne en el Ministerio de Hacienda generó sorpresa entre aquellos que poco conocen a este economista. Es que pese a ser co-conductor del programa ‘Odisea Argentina’ en TN y columnista del diario La Nación, prefiere el perfil bajo. Por ello, entre los hombres de mercado Dujovne es un […]
- #EEUU Obama vuelve a traicionar a Israel, esta vez ante la ONU December 26, 2016El primer ministro de Israel indicó que el mandatario estadounidense “actuó contra su propio compromiso” al no ejercer su derecho a veto en el Consejo de Seguridad y así permitir la resolución que condena los asentamientos judíos. El primer ministro israelí Benjamin Netanyahu acusó al gobierno estadounidense de perpetrar un “vergonzoso golpe anti-israelí en Naciones […]
- #Venezuela Chaos as Nicolas Maduro flip-flops on currency withdrawal December 22, 2016The 100-bolivar bill was nearly worthless already when Venezuela’s President Nicolás Maduro attempted to make it completely useless. The bill fetched just two cents on the black market, 14 cents at the official rate. But it was the highest-denomination bank note in circulation in the country, where one bill was just enough to buy a […]
- #Ecuador Departamento de Justicia de EE.UU. denuncia que la constructora Odebrecht pagó U$S 33,5 millones en sobornos December 21, 2016El Departamento de Justicia de Estados Unidos reveló en un informe este miércoles que el grupo Odebrecht pagó por sobornos unos $ 439 millones de dólares en unos doce países, entre esos Ecuador, donde asegura se pagaron $ 33,5 millones desde 2007 a 2016 para lograr beneficios equivalentes a unos $ 116 millones. La información […]
- Las FARC, el Foro de San Paulo y compañía van por todo Latinoamérica – por María Celsa Rodríguez January 11, 2017
- Niños del Estado Islámico asesinan a 25 soldados siriosYihadistas publican video donde aparecen las víctimas de rodillas y en fila en el escenario del teatro romano de Palmira
- Fidel reaparece en reunión de maestros queserosSostuvo un amplio intercambio de más de cuatro horas con 19 maestros queseros en un instituto en el poblado del Guatao
- Enrique Iglesias complace a miles de fansCon I like it, el cantante finalizó su concierto de anoche
- Kutcher y Mila Kunis se casarían este fin de semanaSegún el portal estadounidense Page Six, la pareja dará el sí en una ceremonia privada en Los Angeles
- Niños del Estado Islámico asesinan a 25 soldados sirios