A significant but under-reported meeting of the Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC) took place on January 28 and 29th in Havana, Cuba.
CELAC is an organization created in order to promote regional integration. It includes almost all the Latin American and Caribbean countries but excludes the United States and Canada. It is also a political organization, created in Caracas in 2011 and inspired by the late Venezuelan president, Hugo Chavez whose implicit aim was to diminish the influence of the Organization of American States (OEA) and the United States.
This summit had strong political connotations with implications for the future of the region. Several key resolutions were adopted.
First, CELAC affirmed the right of each nation to choose any type of “political and economic organization”. By the same token CELAC affirmed its support for the principle “of self-determination, respect for the sovereignty and territorial integrity of each country; and; support for the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of sovereign countries”.
It is interesting that in the same resolution, even in the same sentence, CELAC expresses support for the “protection and promotion of all human rights, respect for the rule of law at the national and international levels and the promotion of citizens’ participation and democracy”.
This first resolution then continues “ we are also committed to work together for the prosperity of all, in such a way that all forms of discrimination, inequality, marginalization, violations of human rights and the rule of law be eradicated”.
Of course this main resolution of CELAC is clearly ambiguous and misleading even though it looks perfectly acceptable to the naked eye. However, if we look carefully, we can see that CELAC is asking that the international community and the region accept any form of political or economic regime chosen by each member country while calling for non-interference in that countries’ internal affairs. In other words, what CELAC is requesting is that if a country chooses to become a dictatorship, it should be accepted without questioning. The principle of sovereignty and self-determination stands above the principle of human rights or liberty.
It is no wonder that the resolution does not call to protect “human rights” but “all human rights”. This language is problematic as it implies that human rights are not just violations of the right to life and liberty but also “social rights” which are fundamentally the right to an income or the right to economic equality.
It is not that social rights are to be dismissed but what would happen if in the name of social rights, human and civil rights are violated?
We can find the answer in the next paragraph where the resolution implies that if prosperity for all is achieved, problems of human rights will be eradicated.
In other words, economic prosperity is directly tied to the diminishing of violations of rights (which for CELAC includes “inequality” as a main component). Common sense tells us that if inequality is indeed a socio-economic problem, civil and human rights are tied to the rule of law independently of economic performance. However, for CELAC the constitutionality and legal character of rights seems to be subjected to economic performance and reduction of inequality.
Thus, CELAC is in fact legitimizing dictatorship.
It is no wonder that leaders from all over the continent visited the old leader of the Cuban revolution, Fidel Castro as if the Caribbean dictator were the Dalai Lama or the Pope. All the presidents, one after another, were there to receive the blessing of the old man. The list included Presidents Dilma Roussef (Brazil), Cristina Kirchner (Argentina), Jose Mujica (Uruguay), Enrique Pena Nieto (Mexico), and, of course the presidents of the countries of the Bolivarian alliance (Venezuela, Bolivia, Ecuador, and Nicaragua).
These meetings actually took place when human rights in Cuba continue to be practically non-existent. In other words there is no freedom of the press, of free speech, and no elections on a municipal or national level. Cuba continues to be a fifty-five year old Communist, anti-American dictatorship that has impoverished the vast majority of its people.
In Cuba there are political prisoners detained without any fair trial. Today, we have a remarkable group of wives of political prisoners called the Ladies in White (Las Damas de Blanco”). This group protests every day in downtown Havana demanding the release of their husbands. The “Ladies in White” follow the model of the “Mothers of Plaza de Mayo”, a group of mothers that during the 1977-1983 military dictatorship in Argentina demanded information about their children who disappeared during that dark time. The “Ladies in White”, like other peaceful opponents of the regime, are constantly subjected to harassment by the Cuban security forces. Likewise, the prison system in Cuba has been described by human rights organizations as “cruel, inhuman and degrading”. The Cuban government continues to refuse to cooperate with the International Red Cross and other humanitarian bodies.
We should not forget the case of Alan Gross, a U.S government sub-contractor for the U.S Agency for International Development (USAID). He was falsely accused of crimes against the Cuban state for bringing computer equipment to Cuba’s Jewish community. He has been a prisoner in Cuba for the last four years and since 2011 he is serving a 15year sentence.
The number of political prisoners has doubled, according to a report by the Miami Herald from a year ago.
Of the 33 leaders at CELAC, only the outgoing Chilean president Sebastian Piñera met with representatives from the “Ladies in White”. In another such gesture, Costa Rica received in its Havana embassy a delegation of Cuban dissidents.
What is worse, the Cuban government is exporting its repression tactics to newly elected dictatorships such as Venezuela.
However, CELAC managed to condemn the U.S. economic blockade against Cuba.
In response, the U.S. State Department rightly accused Latin American countries of “betraying democracy” by giving diplomatic support to Cuba. Even the well- known and widely circulated Spanish leftist newspaper “El País” suggested that the CELAC summit was a farce that only served to legitimize the Castro dictatorship and increase its political capital.
But as a result of the CELAC summit not only the Cuban dictatorship was legitimized but also, all forms of authoritarianism were given legitimacy. That means that no undemocratic country or violator of human rights (as long as he belongs to the “social equalizer” camp) will be condemned or reprimanded by the region.
Secondly, this tendency was reaffirmed by the position of the Mexican government and the European Union.
Mexican President Pena Nieto met with Castro, and contrary to his two predecessors Felipe Calderon and Vicente Fox, totally ignored the dissidents. Pena Nieto also called Castro “Cuba’s moral and political leader” and proceeded to renew relations between the two countries that suffered a breakdown in their relationship (mostly over human rights) since 2002.
Likewise, the European Union announced that it would deepen relations with Cuba. On February 10th, 28 European foreign ministers are expected to give a green light to begin talks with Havana in order to increase trade, investment and dialogue on human rights. I have my doubts that the stubborn Cuban regime will even agree to discuss human rights but it will certainly benefit from European investments. Europe is expected to look for its own economic and political interests. What is worse the EU announcement is a major political victory for the Cuban regime.
Here again, the United States is a passive observer having failed to develop a sound human rights agenda and establish a suitable Latin American policy. Instead, the U.S. has adapted to the “natural” course of events dictated by the likes of Hugo Chavez, Raul Castro, Evo Morales and Rafael Correa.
Luis Fleischman is co-editor of The Americas Report and the author of the book, “Latin America in the Post-Chavez Era: The Security Threat to the United States.”
THE AMERICAS REPORT
NANCY MENGES and
LUIS FLEISCHMAN, Editors
The Americas Report is the featured product of the Center for Security Policy‘s Menges Hemispheric Security Project. It features in-depth, original articles on subjects not regularly covered by the American press.
Search The Americas Report
Browse By Topic
- Central American Countries (6)
- Latin American Countries (244)
- Middle East (24)
- Podcast (1)
- #Venezuela El desgarrador video de Ricardo Montaner para un país que se desangra August 21, 2016En tiempos oscuros, cuando los dictadores, los señores de horca y cuchillo, los que en el poder se creen dueños de vidas y hacienda, y el terror es la única Carta Magna, no hay espada más filosa, y a la larga más letal, que los artistas. Acabo de ver y oír un tema de Ricardo […]
- #Mercosur #Paraguay rompe relaciones diplomáticas con Venezuela August 20, 2016El canciller paraguayo, Eladio Loizaga, afirmó que el embajador en Caracas no regresará a Venezuela. La decisión del gobierno de Horacio Cartes es en respuesta a los insultos de Nicolás Maduro. Paraguay, al igual que Argentina y Brasil, se opone a que Venezuela asuma la presidencia pro témpore del Mercosur con el argumento de que […]
- #Venezuela Maduro amenazó con usar más represión que Erdogan contra la oposición August 19, 2016El presidente ilegítimo de Venezuela, Nicolás Maduro, advirtió este jueves que si la oposición intenta darle un golpe de Estado reaccionará con tanta dureza que el gobernante turco, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, quedará como "un niño de pecho" comparado con su respuesta.
- #US Wikileaks Confirms Hillary Clinton Sold Weapons To ISIS August 15, 2016Although Hillary Clinton has repeatedly denied that she sold weapons to the Islamic Stats while serving as Secretary of State, Wikileaks founder Julian Assange claims he has proof to the contrary. Assange is now stating that 1,700 emails contained in the Clinton cache directly connect Hillary to Libya to Syria, and directly to Al Qaeda […]
- #Venezuela Crisis económica rampante: Ahora ataúdes de cartón August 12, 2016La "revolución" chavista ha logrado que los venezolanos pasen harto trabajo para resolver la vida diaria, pero también para sobrellevar la muerte. El alto costo y la escasez de materiales complican la adquisición de ataúdes, por lo que se están fabricando de tablones baratos y hasta de cartón.
- #Venezuela Venezolanos sufren grave déficit de nutrientes por la escasez y alto costo de alimentos August 11, 2016Los huesos de los venezolanos se están quedando sin calcio. Para gran parte de la población alimentos como la leche y el queso desaparecieron de su mesa. De acuerdo con el Estudio Latinoamericano de Nutrición y Salud (ELANS 2015), 87,8% de los entrevistados admiten no consumirlo, pero los casos más graves se presentaron en las […]
- #Venezuela Balseros huyen a islas del Caribe: “El país te lleva a pensar en salir como sea” August 9, 2016Envalentonados por los menos de 30 kilómetros que los separan de las paradisíacas costas de Aruba y Curazao, cada vez más venezolanos que huyen de la profunda crisis económica en su país eligen las Antillas vecinas, a donde algunos llegan en embarcaciones con motores fuera de borda en una travesía de apenas unas horas, enfrentándose […]
- #Brasil Wall Street Journal: “Lula ha engañado al mundo” August 8, 2016"Si el fraude político por llevar a una nación a la ruina fuera un crimen, Lula y Dilma ya habrían sido condenados," afirma el periódico Wall Street Journal, refiriéndose al desastre de la economía del Brasil que se evidencia mientras el mundo pone sus ojos sobre el país carioca con motivo de los Juegos Olímpicos […]
- #Cuba Over 845 Political Arrests in July, Cuban Repression at Historic Rate August 8, 2016The Cuban Commission for Human Rights (CCHR) has documented 845 political arrests by the Castro regime during the month of July 2016. It already nearly matches last year's year-long tally of 8,616 political arrests. With Obama's policy, it pays to repress.
- #Uruguay Jorge Batlle: “Sin guerrilla no hubiera habido golpe de Estado militar” August 7, 2016El ex Presidente uruguayo Jorge Batlle disparó duro en una columna publicada en su cuenta de Facebook contra la guerrilla tupamara y contra el decreto del presidente Tabaré Vázquez, con el que oficializó al Grupo por Verdad y Justicia que investigará crímenes de lesa humanidad ocurridos durante la última dictadura militar. ¿Se viene el negocio […]
- #Venezuela El desgarrador video de Ricardo Montaner para un país que se desangra August 21, 2016