Chavez continues to be the hero in Venezuela and the region. In the last elections for state governors that took place on Sunday, December 16th, Chavez’s party, the United Socialist Party of Venezuela (PSUV), won overwhelmingly and now holds 20 out of the 23 state governments in the nation.
The opposition lost important states such as Zulia that it had controlled for more than eight years. Likewise, the opposition lost the state of Carabobo, a state that has never been in the hands of a pro-Chavez government. Even in the state of Tachira, which was the only state the opposition won in the October 7th presidential election, was lost to Chavez’s political loyalists.
Those who think that Chavez’s movement will not survive his death should be dissuaded from this belief given the results of this gubernatorial election which proves exactly the opposite.
Populism and the government’s massive use of state resources were key to winning those elections.
In addition, there is an undeniable emotional element that played extremely well among the population. As El Universal journalist, Roberto Giusti, pointed out in a recent forum in Miami, “Chavez used his own illness to achieve political gains. As he flew to Cuba for a new round of cancer treatment, there was a massive national mobilization to pray to God for Chavez’s well being. ” Thus, Chavez’s popularity increased as a result of his martyrdom. If people pray for his health, most probably such prayer could well be translated into support on the ballots. Another Venezuelan journalist called it “an emotional Tsunami”.
Paradoxically, the overwhelming support for Chavez comes as projects aimed at reducing poverty have been stagnant now for six years. Almost, like in a communist
country, 44% of the population works in the informal sector of the economy or an underground economy.
With the rise of populism, based on a welfare economy and worship of the leader, the Venezuelan people have converted themselves from being a civil society into a mob, an amorphous mass of people prone to political manipulation.
The main role of this mob is to support the political power of Chavez and his circle as well as his revolution. Whatever individual or social aspirations they may have are not so important anymore. Their voice is their vote. The channels to place demands are not open. It is up to the state and to the government to decide for them. The government will reward the people with gifts. But God-forbid they make demands of their own. God forbid they demand civil liberties, release of political prisoners or freedom of the press.
When Peronism, the most influential populist regime in history, was in power the people who supported it were often blamed of having sold themselves for “lentil stew”. The sociologist, Gino Germani then responded that those Argentineans who supported Peronism, and particularly the working class, received something material in return but at the same time did not lose anything in terms of civil rights and freedom because what preceded Peron was a decade of military rule where neither civil liberties nor democracy really existed.
However, in the case of Venezuela the situation is different. Although the two parties that ruled Venezuela after the “Punto Fijo Pact” were oligarchical and corrupt, the basic freedoms that a democracy provides were fully maintained.
Venezuelans have now shown that freedom and democracy is not a priority for them except perhaps in the very act of voting. They do not seem at all bothered by the behavior of the Venezuelan Government. Chavez’ as national figure and protector of the poor seems to prevail above anything else.
Though extensively discussed in various articles of the Americas Report, there are numerous examples of repression at various levels of the government under the Chavez regime.
As an illustration of what is now occurring in Venezuela Carlos Alberto Montaner reminded us that Venezuelan judge Maria Lourdes Afiuni provided a verdict on an individual that Chavez wanted to send to jail. Judge Afiuni applied judicial principles and followed the spirit of the law and after a careful review she ordered to release that individual since he already spent three years in preventive custody. Her verdict angered Chavez and led him to order the imprisonment of Judge Afiuni without any legal foundation, just by virtue of arbitrary prerogative.
While in prison Judge Afiuni was raped by several guards and she got pregnant. She was released later because of medical reasons but her house was shot down with gun machines.
Liberty and basic rights are sacrificed in the name of a regime that promotes equality or income distribution. The Chavez regime is not merely about power but it has to be consistent with its ideology of reducing inequality and proceed with a project of income distribution. This is the reason why the Bolivarian Revolution is so acclaimed, after all. It is a “generous” tyranny.
Perhaps, it is why Chavez is so admired by a variety of intellectuals, journalists and other left-wing romantics who are obsessed with the issue of “equality”, “wealth or income distribution”.
The well-known economist and political theorist, Thomas Sowell has made the following point: “If there really were some pre-existing body of income or wealth, produced somehow –manna from heaven, as it were-then there would be of course a moral question as to how large a share each member of society should receive. But wealth is produced. It does not exist somehow”. 
Productivity is the result of a number of factors that include initiative, entrepreneurship and, of course also labor plus other factors such as education. Empirically speaking capitalist societies have been more productive than non-capitalist societies because freedom of enterprise and a market society enabled individual creativity that were converted into initiatives. These initiatives created wealth, provided employment and increased the purchasing power of the people. It is no wonder that the Soviet Union and its communist satellites collapsed. No initiative, no creativity, and no productivity were encouraged. A mighty military co-existed alongside a bankrupt and decrepit civil society. Let us recognize that in a market society there could be an element of exploitation or unfairness between those who own or manage and those who work or hold positions at lower levels. This is why labor unions have played the role of reducing those gaps. However, these gap reductions have not been aimed at creating pure equality, (particularly when economic growth or wealth production often brings about inequality). These labor conflicts were aimed at providing fair income to the workers, not to create equality of income across the board.
Where then does the Bolivarian “equality” lead us?
Since Venezuela is a producer of oil, and since that industry is managed by a state company where the government has constantly interfered in its management, the 21st Century Socialist revolution is going to lead to a regime similar to the one held by Arab oil secular tyrannies and monarchies such as Saadam Hussein’s Iraq, Gadaffi’s Libya and Saudi Arabia.
None of these autocratic rulers have ruled with the power of repression alone. They were more sophisticated than that. They used oil income to distribute wealth and to co-opt dissenters. This policy not only created a lack of economic diversity and served to minimize individual creativity, but also reduced entrepreneurship and personal responsibility.
This is going to be the fate of the Venezuelans that had agreed to live under this setting. They will continue to receive government’s gifts and bring no initiative until the price of commodities in the international market will collapse altogether. Then they will become more impoverished than they ever had been.
This is going to have tremendous consequences for the Venezuelans’ work ethic and productivity. By contrast, as Chilean journalist, Lorena Medel pointed out at the same conference in Miami, in Chile “people look for opportunities to be productive, not for Government charity”.
But it is this Venezuelan “Arab” model that it is celebrated not only in the countries of the Bolivarian alliance, but also in the “Europeanized”, modern Buenos Aires. This is particularly true for those intellectuals and opinion leaders close to the government of Cristina Kirchner. The grassroots of the Brazilian Workers Party (PT) and the Movement for Popular Participation (MPP), the strongest sector within the ruling Broad Front in Uruguay, also admires this model. Even the ultra- atheist President of Uruguay, Jose Mujica, joined the prayers for Chavez’s health.
There is no sector within the Latin American left, even among the social-democrats, that does not have a pro-Chavez sector in their ranks.
The Chavistas have also managed to silence their critics. Many may not like Chavismo and Bolivarianismo in private but they cannot display such antipathy in public. Even conservative governments like those in Colombia and Chile have to pay this lip service in order not to be marginalized in the region and benefit from regional integration.
This shows that the Bolivarian Revolution has enough hegemonic power to exercise its veto up to the point that many leaders (including the more rational Brazilian President Dilma Roussef) mistakenly believe that the survival of the Bolivarian regime in Venezuela is a necessary condition for the successful continuity of regional integration. In fact, regional integration is in the interests also of conservative countries in the region such as those mentioned above. Hugo Chavez or his accomplices do not constitute a necessary condition for the survival of regional integration. Any president or leader would like to benefit from such integration.
Even the United States government has accepted this code of silence by adopting a passive attitude thus leaving our allies at the mercy of this new regional “common understanding”.
All the Bolivarian Revolution needs now is just enough support from his allies and enough silence from those who are not.
 Thomas Sowells, Intellectuals and Society, Basic Boos, New York, 2011, p. 50-51
THE AMERICAS REPORT
NANCY MENGES and
LUIS FLEISCHMAN, Editors
The Americas Report is the featured product of the Center for Security Policy‘s Menges Hemispheric Security Project. It features in-depth, original articles on subjects not regularly covered by the American press.
Search The Americas Report
Browse By Topic
- Central American Countries (13)
- Latin American Countries (316)
- Middle East (30)
- Podcast (1)
- #Argentina Salir de la locura – por Carlos Mira August 31, 2018De nada sirve decir “se los dije”. Cuando el agua le llega a uno al cuello, todo ese tipo de “reverberancias” ya no aportan ninguna solución. Pero lo que ocurre es que el gobierno, por sus principales figuras es el que está diciendo: “me lo dijiste”. Haber mentido en el instante de mayor poder de […]
- #Bolivia Socialismo Siglo XXI…OTRO MÁS que toma el camino de la DICTADURA August 24, 2018El 21 de Febrero de 2016 el pueblo de Bolivia dijo NO a la cuarta reelección de Evo Morales en un referendum del que participaron todos los bolivianos. Sin embargo, Morales ahora busca desconocer la voluntad de su gente, volviendo a presentarse como candidato. Una decisión que establece formalmente una dictadura en Bolivia. Para de […]
- #Argentina Queremos flan – por Fernando Iglesias August 22, 2018“Vamos a decir la verdad: a vos se te prendió fuego la casa, afuera hace frío y tenés 12 hijos. Entonces vienen los 12 y te dicen: ¡Queremos flan! ¡Queremos flan, papá! ¡Flaaaaaaannn! Y cuando vos intentás explicarles que unos HdP le prendieron fuego a la casa, ellos te contestan que no es cierto, que […]
- #Nicaragua OEA condena violaciones de DDHH y exige elecciones anticipadas July 19, 2018La OEA condenó este miércoles las violaciones a los derechos humanos cometidos por la policía y paramilitares del régimen, desde que comenzaron a mediados de abril, las protestas pacíficas contra el autócrata Daniel Ortega cuya represión ya lleva 350 muertos y 2.000 heridos, habiendo ausencia de libertad de expresión, y denegación de atención médica a heridos. […]
- #Ecuador ¿Se enfría la economía ecuatoriana? – por Jorge Calderón Salazar July 17, 2018Días atrás culminó la visita del Fondo Monetario Internacional y durante la cual se reunió con varios representantes tanto del sector público como privado, pero más allá de este proceso iniciado meses atrás por el gobierno en aras de tender puentes con este organismo multilateral y mejorar así de a poco su imagen en los […]
- #Nicaragua EL PODER… sin importar la sangre que se tenga que pagar July 2, 2018Daniel Ortega autoriza ingreso de tropas de Cuba y Venezuela a Nicaragua. La mayoría del Parlamento de Nicaragua autorizó este viernes el ingreso de tropas y medios extranjeros entre julio y diciembre de 2018 con fines humanitarios, a pesar de que la oposición lo consideró “imprudente” en medio de la represión contra las protestas antigubernamentales. […]
- #Mexico Elecciones: Inversores aterrorizados mientras izquierda celebra a López Obrador July 2, 2018Nicolás Maduro, Dilma Rousseff, Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, Gustavo Petro, Rafael Correa y Pablo Iglesias, dirigentes políticos de la izquierda de América Latina y España, han apoyado primero y luego felicitado a Andrés Manuel López Obrador, por su triunfo en las elecciones presidenciales en México con el 53% de los votos. Inversores aterrorizados por las perspectivas […]
- #Colombia Contundente triunfo del sentido común: Iván Duque es el nuevo presidente June 17, 2018Con tan sólo 41 años y excelentes propuestas para el futuro de Colombia, Iván Duque, el candidato del Centro Democrático, se impuso sobre el ex terrorista del M19 Gustavo Petro, en segunda vuelta electoral por 54% a 42%. Duque asumirá el poder hasta el año 2022. Colombia celebra un nuevo triunfo del uribismo sobre el […]
- #Bolivia Evo Morales llega a Rusia: ¿Cumbre con Putin o viaje gratis al mundial? June 14, 2018El canciller boliviano, Fernando Huanacuni Mamani anunció que Evo Morales, presidente del narcoestado boliviano, se ha reunido ayer con Vladimir Putin en Rusia para gestionar USD 1.000 millones en inversiones. Pero la oposición denuncia que este viaje, que costará USD 340.000 en fondos públicos, sirve de excusa para que el gran jefe cocalero no se pierda la […]
- #Venezuela Lech Walesa: “Venezuela está secuestrada por un grupo de neo traficantes y terroristas” June 13, 2018Lech Walesa, líder polaco de la revolución de terciopelo en Europa, sostuvo que Venezuela está secuestrada por “un grupo de neo traficantes y terroristas” y “que más temprano que tarde, deberá ser intervenida por fuerzas de coalición internacional para preservar la paz mundial”. Las declaraciones del expresidente de Polonia fueron reflejadas por Antonio Ledezma en […]
- #Argentina Salir de la locura – por Carlos Mira August 31, 2018
- Niños del Estado Islámico asesinan a 25 soldados siriosYihadistas publican video donde aparecen las víctimas de rodillas y en fila en el escenario del teatro romano de Palmira
- Fidel reaparece en reunión de maestros queserosSostuvo un amplio intercambio de más de cuatro horas con 19 maestros queseros en un instituto en el poblado del Guatao
- Enrique Iglesias complace a miles de fansCon I like it, el cantante finalizó su concierto de anoche
- Kutcher y Mila Kunis se casarían este fin de semanaSegún el portal estadounidense Page Six, la pareja dará el sí en una ceremonia privada en Los Angeles
- Niños del Estado Islámico asesinan a 25 soldados sirios